Disney pin trading started in 1999 as a small park promotion. Today it is a full-blown collecting hobby with thousands of pin designs, a thriving secondary market, and its own culture of trading etiquette that new collectors need to learn before showing up at a pin board.
If you just bought your first pin at Magic Kingdom, or if you have a lanyard with 200 pins and no way to keep track of them, this guide covers both ends.
How Disney Pin Trading Works
Every Disney cast member wearing a lanyard with pins is required to trade with you if you ask. That is the official rule. You offer one of your pins, they let you pick one of theirs. No negotiation, no refusal (as long as your pin is an official Disney pin and not a scrapper or counterfeit).
This is how most new collectors get started. Buy a cheap starter set at the park, trade with cast members, and build from there.
The Unwritten Rules
- Don’t trade scrappers (counterfeit pins). Cast members are trained to spot them, and experienced traders will refuse them.
- You can trade with other guests, but unlike cast member trades, guests can say no.
- Condition matters for valuable pins. Scratched enamel or missing backings reduce trade value.
- Limited Edition (LE) pins have a specific production count stamped on the back. The lower the number, the more desirable the pin.
Types of Disney Pins
Open Edition (OE): Standard pins sold in parks and online. Produced in large quantities. Good for trading, but rarely valuable on the secondary market. $8-$15 retail.
Limited Edition (LE): Produced in a specific quantity (LE 500, LE 2000, LE 5000, etc). The number is on the back. Lower LE numbers are more valuable. LE 500 or below can sell for $30-$100+ depending on the design.
Limited Release (LR): Produced for a limited time but without a specific production count. Less predictable in value than LE pins.
Hidden Mickey Pins: Cast member pins with a small Mickey head icon on the back. Traded exclusively through cast member lanyards. Some Hidden Mickey sets are highly collectible.
Completer Pins: Special pins you receive for completing a specific set. You trade the required pins to a cast member at a pin trading location, and they give you the completer. These are often valuable because fewer people complete the full set.
How to Organize Your Pin Collection
This is where most pin collectors hit a wall. You have 200 pins and no idea which ones you have, which ones you’re missing from a set, or what any of them are worth.
iCollect Everything solves this. Catalog your pins with photos, organize by series and theme, track which ones are LE vs OE, and manage a wishlist of pins you are looking for. You can share your collection via a web link when arranging trades with other collectors.
 |
 |
How to Spot Fake (Scrapper) Pins
Scrapper pins are counterfeit Disney pins made from rejected molds or unauthorized copies. They look close to real pins but have telltale differences:
- Rough edges. Real Disney pins have smooth, clean enamel edges. Scrappers often have bumpy or uneven enamel.
- Dull colors. The enamel colors on scrappers are often slightly off. Compare against a known-real version of the same pin.
- Thin or light feel. Scrappers are frequently thinner and lighter than authentic pins. Hold a known-real pin in one hand and the suspect pin in the other.
- Missing or wrong backstamp. Real Disney pins have a specific backstamp (Disney Parks, Disney Trading Pin, etc). Scrappers may have wrong text, blurry printing, or no backstamp at all.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best app for tracking Disney pins?
iCollect Everything is the best pin collection app. Catalog your pins with photos, track LE numbers, organize by series, and manage a trading wishlist. Share your collection via a web link for trading. Free on iPhone, Android, Mac, and Windows.
Are Disney pins worth money?
Open edition pins are generally worth $5-$10 on the secondary market. Limited edition pins (LE 500 and below) can be worth $30-$100+. Rare completer pins and early LE pins from 2000-2010 can be worth even more.
How do I start a Disney pin collection?
Buy a starter trading set at any Disney park gift shop (around $20 for a set of 4-6 pins). Start trading with cast members to build your collection. Pick a theme or character you love and focus on completing sets rather than collecting randomly.